Why they built it
Founder Nikki Durkin saw women accumulated clothes they stopped wearing yet felt guilty buying more. She built a peer-to-peer marketplace to trade unwanted dresses using a proprietary virtual currency called buttons for guilt-free shopping. A Facebook event that drew 40,000 RSVPs and an Australian pilot with 4,500 dresses uploaded and 3,500 sold convinced her it was worth building.
Why it didn't work out
The day after signing a $1.2 million seed round after YC Winter 2012 Demo Day, both co-founders left and the $1.2 million never reached the company's account. Durkin salvaged about $595,000 and rebuilt the team, which delayed the US mobile launch until September 2013, by which time US users rejected buttons and competitors had scaled. The company shut down in June 2014 after four years of operation.
What went wrong
Most important first.
- 1
Both co-founders quit after seed signing Team
Peter Delahunty and Dan Walker left without warning the day after the $1.2M seed round was signed, leaving Durkin as sole non-technical founder with no engineering leadership.
- 2
Seed funding collapsed in half Capital
The $1.2M never reached the account and Durkin closed a reduced $595,000 round including Draper Associates and Pegasus Tech Ventures.
- 3
Buttons worked in Australia but not in the US Product-market fit
The buttons closed-loop economy drove 78% sell-through in Australia but US users did not respond, forcing a September 2013 iOS rebuild to a karma model for items under $60 plus cash for higher-end items.
- 4
18-month delay let competitors take the market Competition
Between March 2012 Demo Day and the September 2013 iOS launch, Poshmark, ThredUp and Tradesy established cash-based resale and flooded the space.
- 5
Technical dependency and sales-halting failures Technology
Durkin did not code or know how to work with developers, and massive technology fuckups brought sales to a halt after losing the technical co-founder.
- 6
O-1 visa delay burned runway Regulation
Additional processing at the US consulate in Sydney delayed Durkin's US entry by about a month while the startup burned cash.
What could be different today
- US secondhand apparel grew from $28B in 2019 to a projected $82B by 2026 per ThredUp's 2024 Resale Report, with Depop sold to Etsy for $1.6B in 2021 and Poshmark to Naver for $1.2B in 2022 validating resale at scale.
- AI listing via GPT-4V released November 2023, Google Vision, and eBay's 2023 auto-tag tools can generate brand, size, condition and price from a single photo, removing manual listing work.
- Platform currencies like Roblox Robux and Fortnite V-Bucks have made closed-loop currencies fluent for users under 30, lowering education overhead for buttons.
- Stripe Connect now handles peer-to-peer payouts, escrow and dispute resolution out of the box.
- TikTok Shop launched in the US in 2023 and Instagram Shopping let inventory surface inside existing social behavior instead of cold-start community building.